Another season has concluded, and Aaron Judge continues to demonstrate why he is a frontrunner for the American League (AL) MVP award. Even as the New York Yankees narrowly missed securing the AL East title—falling just short against the Toronto Blue Jays in a tiebreaker—Judge’s performance has solidified his status as one of the league’s elite hitters.
A Season of Historical Proportions
Despite a subdued outing during Game 162 against the Baltimore Orioles, where he went 1-for-4, Judge’s overall season average is nothing short of extraordinary. He concluded the 2025 season with an impressive slash line of .331/.457/.688, hitting 53 home runs and driving in 114 runs across 152 games. This remarkable performance earned him a 10+ Wins Above Replacement (WAR) rating from Fangraphs for the third time in four seasons, placing him firmly at the top among his peers vying for the MVP title.
The Yankees are actively championing Judge’s candidacy on social media, utilizing an array of statistics to bolster his case. They highlighted his league-leading 1.145 OPS—nearly .200 points ahead of his closest competitor—along with his record-setting 53 home runs for a batting champion, 10.1 Fangraphs WAR, and an astounding 36 intentional walks. This last statistic stands out, as it exceeds the total of intentional walks recorded by all other 29 MLB teams combined that season.
Narrative and Voter Sentiment
While Judge’s statistical achievements make a compelling case for MVP honors, narratives and voter fatigue may play a significant role in the award’s outcome. This year, the spotlight is not just on Judge; emerging talents are also garnering attention.
Competition from Cal Raleigh
One noteworthy contender is Cal Raleigh of the Seattle Mariners, who has captured the imagination of fans as Seattle surged to an AL West championship. Raleigh boasts a charming personality and a powerful switch-hitting ability. As a catcher, he plays a demanding position, and his 9.0 WAR underscores his impact on the field. Although Judge remains the superior hitter, Raleigh’s role in the Mariners’ success could appeal to voters who favor a compelling narrative around team achievement and player versatility.
The Complexities of MVP Voting
The MVP award is often influenced by more than just numbers. While Judge’s extraordinary performance backs up his candidacy, the storylines woven throughout the season can sway votes. With both Judge’s stellar statistics and Raleigh’s dynamic presence in mind, it remains to be seen how voters will weigh these competing narratives in the fight for the MVP award.
In conclusion, as the dust settles on this MLB season, fans can expect a thrilling MVP race ahead. Aaron Judge’s remarkable statistics make a powerful argument for recognition, yet the allure of fresh narratives could alter the course of history. No matter the outcome, the 2025 season will be remembered as a hallmark year for both Judge and the Yankees.
Image Source: Conor P. Fitzgerald / Shutterstock
